Deconstructing Ohio's New Learning Standards

This article first appeared in the April 2014 issue of the Ohio School Boards Association Journal magazine. Copyright 2014, Ohio School Boards Association. All rights reserved. Reprinted with permission. Follow the association on Twitter, Facebook, and on its website at www.ohioschoolboards.org.


Ohio’s New Learning Standards represent a significant opportunity for students. The new standards are intended to ensure students are college and career ready and prepared to compete in a global economy. They also represent a challenge for Ohio’s educators. The new standards are more rigorous and require educators to plan for instruction and assessment in new and innovative ways. Educators across the state are already using the new standards, but how can we be confident we are implementing the standards with the appropriate levels of expectation and rigor?

An essential step in ensuring curriculum, instruction and assessment are all aligned to the standards is to deconstruct the standards. Deconstruction is the process of breaking down a broad or complex standard into smaller, more explicit learning targets. The terms “unpack” or “unwrap” often are used to describe the same process.

Why is this step so crucial? Below are four ways that working through the deconstruction process can bring clarity to standards implementation.

1. Clarifying expectations

Deconstruction helps teachers better understand the content that is embedded in the standard so it can be accurately taught and assessed. Standards are broad statements about what students should know and be able to do. Often, they are complex and need to be broken down into smaller, more focused learning targets.

For example, Ohio’s New Learning Standards for social studies include broad content statements organized around conceptual understandings. These content statements are not meant to be taught in a single lesson or even a single unit of study. Teachers will need to break down these broad statements of content into focused learning targets for daily instruction and assessment.

An example from seventh-grade social studies shows how a complex standard can be deconstructed into smaller, more manageable learning targets. Clear learning targets are the foundation of formative instructional practice (FIP). They serve as incremental steps to bigger, more conceptual understandings built over time, providing clarity to both teachers and students about the intended learning.

2. Building understanding and ownership

Collectively working through the deconstruction process helps teachers understand and take ownership of the expected learning. Ohio’s New Learning Standards require that teachers work together — across grade levels and between subject areas — to create learning progressions that make sense for their students. Working together to write learning targets helps create a shared understanding of expectations for student learning. Teachers can come to an understanding of what the standard requires students to know and be able to do, informing decisions about instructional strategies and assessment methods.

Districts across the state are finding the deconstruction process valuable to implementing new standards.

“We do want to deconstruct and look at some of these things for ourselves, because that’s when we really start to internalize and then we take ownership as a building or district,” said Anthony Elkins, supervisor of elementary curriculum at Olentangy Local (Delaware). “With the new standards, you’re not going to be able to implement well without collaboration time built in. Without a common understanding, you’re running in isolation.”

Understanding and ownership of expectations also can be fostered in students by sharing learning targets. When students understand where they are going, they can determine where they are in relation to the learning targets and take more ownership for how they will move forward.

3. Meeting rigorous expectations

Deconstructing the standard can help teachers understand how to teach and assess at the level of rigor or cognitive demand that is the intent of the standard. One of the goals of Ohio’s New Learning Standards is to increase the rigor of our expectations for student learning. This goal can only be realized if we are providing students with instruction and assessment at the appropriate level of rigor as defined by the standards.

“Clear learning targets are very important as you’re looking at assessment practices and really making sure that your assessments are aligned to standards and to instruction,” Elkins said.

4. Creating learning progressions

Finally, the deconstruction process helps teachers understand the learning that comes before and after the standard. Strong formative instructional practice includes creating learning targets at three levels: laying the base, mastery and going beyond. Looking at the learning that comes before and after mastery can help teachers create learning progressions for their students that start where students enter the learning and take them to mastery and beyond.

Sometimes the relevant “before-and-after” learning comes within a school year or course, while for some standards the relevant before-and-after learning comes in the grades or courses before and after the standard being taught. In the English/language arts example (see chart below), the foundational learning, shown in the laying the base sample target, comes from the prior grade, while the going beyond learning is from the subsequent grade.

 

Vertical alignment and learning progressions are two more reasons that collaborative time for educators to deconstruct standards is so important.

“With the new standards, you have to have that vertical articulation,” Elkins said. “If you’re only focused on your grade level, it can lead to a checklist mentality. Instead, you need to understand what comes before, what comes after and what the common expectations are. It is possible.

“Like with anything else, if it’s something you value, you’re going to make time for it. Sometimes you have to be creative in how you structure the time.”

Resources to help with the deconstruction process

Through FIP Your School Ohio, the Ohio Department of Education, in collaboration with Battelle for Kids, has created resources to assist educators with formative instructional practices, including the deconstruction of standards. All of Ohio’s educators have access to free online learning modules, blended learning tools, deconstruction templates and content area examples.

Of course, using clear learning targets to drive instruction and assessment isn’t a new idea. But the complexity and rigor of Ohio’s New Learning Standards make the deconstruction process even more important to ensuring that teachers and students truly understand what the new standards entail.

Creating clear learning targets also can be beneficial to parents. If parents are wondering what’s expected of their children in the new standards, sharing these smaller, easier-to-understand statements can be useful in communicating learning expectations.

If your school is working through the deconstruction process, you may want use the FIP Your School Ohio resources and video library. Visit www.FIPYourSchoolOhio.org to access these tools and learn more about formative instructional practices.

Editor’s note: Virginia Ressa is project coordinator for FIP Your School Ohio in the Ohio Department of Education’s Office of Curriculum and Assessment.